The Greens will not stop fighting to improve access to justice for victim-survivors of domestic, family and sexual violence

Today in Parliament, Abigail secured 8 Greens amendments to the Criminal Procedure and Other Legislation Amendment (Victim Experience Reforms) Bill 2026 to strengthen the rights of victim-survivors of sexual, domestic and family violence within the criminal justice system.

Abigail said:

I contribute to debate on the Criminal Procedure and Other Legislation Amendment (Victim Experience Reforms) Bill 2026 on behalf of The Greens as our gendered violence and abuse spokesperson. This bill introduces several separate reforms that seek to improve the experiences of victim‑survivors of sexual, domestic and family violence by addressing gaps in the criminal justice system. This includes introducing a pilot scheme for ground rules hearings and enabling recorded police statements for adult sexual violence victim-survivors, making some minor technical amendments to the sexual assault communications privilege and expanding procedural protections for domestic violence victim-survivors.

I note from the outset that The Greens welcome many of the reforms in the bill. However, we hold grave concerns about the approach taken by this Labor Government when it comes to actually listening to and delivering on the calls of victim-survivors, experts and advocates who have been fighting for bold, transformative reforms to improve access to justice for sexual violence victim-survivors. I extend my deepest gratitude and appreciation to the survivor advocates and experts driving powerful advocacy campaigns across the country to push for reform of our criminal justice systems. To all those who continue to fight for a fair, safe and equitable justice system for victim-survivors, The Greens stand with you today and every day in this ongoing fight. We will not stop pushing for radical, systemwide change that puts the interests and autonomy of victim-survivors first.

In particular, I acknowledge the campaign for pre-recorded testimony, led by Fair Agenda and survivor‑advocates including Brittany Higgins and Elaheh Taheri, which has been calling on the New South Wales Government to give sexual violence victim-survivors the right to choose to pre-record their testimony during evidence-in-chief, cross-examination and re-examination in a safe and supportive setting. This campaign has been endorsed by 26 organisations including Domestic Violence NSW, Full Stop Australia, Women's Legal Service NSW, Women's Health NSW, No To Violence, With You We Can, Older Women's Network, the Royal Australian and New Zealand College of Psychiatrists and the Justice and Equity Centre.

Reporting sexual violence and seeking justice should not cause further harm, but in a system that is already stacked against victim-survivors, this is far too often the case. Sexual assault is the least likely violent crime to be reported, investigated, prosecuted and convicted. Only a small proportion of reported sexual assault incidents result in the commencement of criminal proceedings, and even fewer result in a criminal conviction. When a victim-survivor does make it past the initial barriers and goes to court, so often they are retraumatised and faced with significant obstacles at nearly every step of the way to seeking justice. We need urgent action to dismantle these structural barriers and rebuild a system that genuinely works for those who it is supposed to help and protect.

In the over the seven years that I have had responsibility for the gender violence portfolio for The Greens, I have had the privilege and honour of working with victim-survivors, frontline workers and expert advocates, who have shared their deep understanding of gendered violence. These experts have told us time and again exactly what is required to eliminate violence against women and children and improve access to justice, recovery and healing. The campaign to allow victim-survivors to pre-record their evidence is just one of the survivor-led reforms that The Greens are proud to champion.

Back in November 2025 the New South Wales upper House passed my motion recognising Fair Agenda's campaign, which at the time had already received support from thousands of individuals, experts and organisations. My motion called on the New South Wales Government to allow adult victim-survivors of sexual violence to choose how they give evidence in court by ensuring that they have access to, and autonomy to choose to rely on, pre-recorded evidence for evidence-in-chief, cross-examination and re-examination in a safe and supportive setting. Importantly, it also called for investment in training for court staff, funding for frontline services supporting victim-survivors and investment in high-quality, accessible facilities and technology for courts including remote witness rooms, secure evidence storage and recording equipment. Since then, we have seen no movement whatsoever from the Minns Labor Government to provide any of that investment, which is absolutely vital for creating a framework that will allow our court processes to facilitate pre-recorded evidence hearings.

Giving evidence requires a victim-survivor to recount some of the most traumatic moments of their life. It means they will be questioned on specific details of sexual violence committed against them in minute and graphic detail, which is an extremely distressing process. Even before a victim-survivor gives their evidence, the period of waiting for trial can be one of the most challenging experiences that a victim-survivor may have, causing stress and anxiety during a time when they are already going through the lengthy process of healing and recovery. It sometimes take years before a victim-survivor finally makes it into a courtroom to give evidence, where they are then forced to relive the assault and grilled on minute and graphic details years down the track. Allowing victim-survivors to pre-record their testimony ahead of trial would empower them to have their voices heard through evidence without risking being retraumatised.

But instead of delivering on this reform, or even making a commitment to doing so, the New South Wales Labor Government has introduced this bill. While this bill does contain some important reforms, including procedural protections for domestic violence victim-survivors and the establishment of ground rules hearings for adult sexual violence victim-survivors, New South Wales Labor has presented it to the media as somehow being a major win for the pre-record campaign. Not only does the bill categorically fail to deliver on the pre-record campaign, it takes us on a route that could very well derail the progress made in this space. Fair Agenda has said that while most of the reforms in the bill reflect some small steps forward, it is not what survivors, advocates and experts have been asking for. Fair Agenda stated in its media release:

The NSW Government's announcement does not deliver the reform victim-survivors have been calling for.

To reduce the harm and additional trauma caused by our current court system:

We've been calling for survivors to pre-record their full testimony in a special hearing, not to increase reliance on police interviews. We've been calling for the government to enable survivors to pre-record their full testimony through special hearings - because it reduces the harm of trial delay; reduces the stress associated with cross-examination; and ensures improved quality of evidence through more timely capture.

We are extremely concerned that rather than delivering the reform called for by survivors, this plan instead shifts a vital part of the testimony for the court process from experienced prosecutors, to local police.

The Greens hold serious concerns about the risks of introducing recorded police statements without first implementing a robust pre-record framework across the justice system for evidence-in-chief, cross-examination and re-examination. These concerns do not come from only The Greens.

The shortcomings of recorded police statements are well evidenced and have also been raised by the gendered violence sector, including Fair Agenda and Women's Legal Service NSW, who have been championing full prerecorded evidence hearings with questioning by trained lawyers and not police officers as a matter of priority and urgency. It is disappointing that the New South Wales Labor Government has chosen to rush through the adoption of recorded police statements instead of making a commitment ahead of the upcoming State election in March 2027 to full prerecording, backed up by significant investment. In its 2025 Safe, Informed, Supported report, the Australian Law Reform Commission carefully examined the merits and shortcomings of recorded police statements. It found:

... systemic problems with recorded police statements have endured for a significant period. In those circumstances, resources and expertise need to be focused upon addressing these concerns rather than calling for more funding to extend a measure which is known to be problematic.

The Australian Capital Territory's framework of widely using recorded police statements has been critiqued for several years on the basis that victim‑survivors are not being afforded choice and autonomy as to whether to participate in a recorded interview. Officers frequently do not gather evidence, including failing to take any steps to secure perishable evidence, until after a recorded police statement is complete and victim‑survivors are frequently pushed by police to either participate in a recorded statement or withdraw their report entirely. We must avoid that situation in New South Wales.

I note that if victim‑survivors were guaranteed to be referred to independent legal advice before they elect how to provide their statement, many of those risks would likely be mitigated. However, the reality is that independent legal advice and representation for victim‑survivors of sexual violence is not guaranteed in New South Wales and it is likely that pushing ahead with increasing reliance on police interviews will cause further harm to victim‑survivors. The Greens will move an amendment to make it a requirement for police to inform survivors of their right to be represented before they consent to a recorded interview, which is such an incredibly bare minimum requirement that should be the norm.

The use of recorded police statements is currently in place in New South Wales for people under 16 years of age or people with a cognitive impairment who are able to elect to give their evidence‑in‑chief in criminal proceedings via a recorded police interview. The bill seeks to allow complainants or a tendency witness in prescribed sexual offences to complete and use a recorded police interview in the same way. Though these provisions allow for the court to order a recording not be used in proceedings if it is satisfied it is not in the interests of justice to do so, The Greens are concerned at the lack of safeguards in place to prevent potential harm occurring as we have seen in other jurisdictions such as the Australian Capital Territory.

The legislation needs to make absolutely clear that it is a victim's choice to make a recorded statement or not, and they must be supported and empowered to give their informed consent. If a victim does not consent to partake in a recorded interview, they must be given the opportunity to make a written statement instead. As it is currently drafted, the bill includes no such provision, which is deeply concerning and goes to the crux of our opposition to the bill's provisions regarding recorded police statements. The Greens will move an amendment to address this. I urge the Government to ensure that these changes are accompanied by a comprehensive, independent monitoring framework to actively monitor the quality of recorded police statements. I also emphasise the need for robust, trauma‑informed training and interviewing guidelines for police officers conducting recorded statements.

I now turn to the establishment of a pilot scheme for ground rules hearings for adult sexual violence proceedings, which is an important step forward in improving access to justice for victim‑survivors and is broadly supported by experts, victim‑survivors and advocates. The Greens, like many across the sector, are disappointed that this has not been established as a permanent scheme available to all victim‑survivors rather than being limited to select areas on a trial basis. If implemented well, the introduction of ground rules hearings could significantly improve the experiences of victim‑survivors in the court process. In particular, it has the potential to prevent further re‑traumatisation. The three‑year pilot will run from 31 March 2027 to 30 June 2030 and will be trialled in three locations—in Parramatta, Dubbo and Wollongong.

Schedule 1 [41] to the bill lays out the conduct of ground rules hearings, including that they must be held before the complainant gives evidence in a hearing for the proceedings, that further ground rules hearings may be held at any stage if the court believes it is in the interest of justice, that the prosecutor and the accused person's legal practitioner—or the accused person if they are unrepresented—must attend the hearings, and that the court must consider the communication, support or other needs of the complainant relevant to giving evidence and may give directions or orders the court considers appropriate in relation to the conduct of proceedings, including in relation to the questioning of the complainant. These provisions also clarify that the court has the power to give directions about the duration, manner or topics of questioning, as well as about the use of communication aids to support the complainant.

The Greens welcome the requirement for complainants to complete a needs assessment questionnaire with the assistance of a witness assistance service officer, which I understand will be designed in consultation with stakeholders and victim‑survivors to ensure it is fit for purpose. It is unfortunate that the bill fails to ensure that all complainants are entitled to independent legal representation through this pilot scheme. I note that in Victoria, where ground rules hearings are mandated for all sexual offence trials and witness intermediaries are required to attend ground rules hearings, the Victims of Crime Commissioner has emphasised the need for victim‑survivors to have access to independent legal representation during ground rules hearings, as well as throughout the entire court process. The Greens firmly believe that all victim‑survivors deserve access to independent legal representation, including at ground rules hearings, and that these representatives must have adequate standing to appear in court to advocate for the victim‑survivor.

If we are not even at the stage of embedding this within a limited pilot scheme for ground rules hearings, how on earth can we ever expect to get to a place where all victim‑survivors have access to independent legal representation from reporting through to the entire court process? Of course, we must ensure that the workforce actually exists on the ground, which requires significant government investment in supporting and bolstering the workforce. This cannot happen when we have governments that are not only failing to do this but also cutting funding for legal aid. In the most recent budget Legal Aid NSW received a 3.6 per cent funding cut for 2026-27 to the tune of around $24 million. Those cuts have already resulted in Legal Aid NSW being forced to significantly curtail several programs and services, while also having to cease some services entirely, like the domestic violence unit's face-to-face outreach services at women's health centres.

I turn now to changes in the bill that address some operational issues concerning the sexual assault communications privilege [SACP] provisions in the Criminal Procedure Act 1986. Unfortunately, the bill makes no attempt at making substantive reform of the sexual assault communications privilege framework, which is one of the key campaigns in the sexual violence law reform advocacy space. The sexual assault communications privilege amendments in the bill will have a limited impact on select cases, rather than addressing the longstanding, systemic flaws in the framework that are actively causing distress and harm to victim‑survivors. The bill amends the SACP provisions in the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 by inserting a new section 298 (2) (a) that provides that, except with the leave of the court, a person cannot be given access to a document recording a protected confidence produced in, or in connection with, any criminal proceedings. This means that a person must seek the court's leave to access a protected confidence that has been produced in criminal proceedings. This will close a small loophole identified by the New South Wales Court of Criminal Appeal in multiple cases.

The bill also amends section 299B (1) of the Act to qualify the court's discretion—which is currently unlimited—to consider a document or evidence when a question arises under the SACP provisions, which clarifies that the court must only consider a document or evidence if it is necessary to do so. Schedule 2 amends the Children (Criminal Proceedings) Act 1987 to clarify how the SACP applies to proceedings for different types of indictable offences in the Children's Court of New South Wales. These amendments seek to act on technical gaps in the current model identified over the years by various stakeholders. It is important to acknowledge the New South Wales Government's recent announcement of an independent research project regarding protecting complainants' counselling communications, which is incredibly limited in scope.

The Greens are deeply concerned that this project is limited to counselling communications, which are only one small aspect of the broader, harmful privacy invasions that victim‑survivors are currently being subjected to, and which perpetrators of abuse commonly utilise as a form of systems abuse and control. A victim‑survivor's phone records—sometimes the entire contents of their phone—are one type of highly sensitive, personal record that are commonly subpoenaed. Not only is this an incredible violation of a person's privacy and autonomy, but these breaches can reduce a victim‑survivor's willingness to engage with the court process in the first place and seriously impede the administration of justice. As researchers Julia Quilter and Luke McNamara put it in their 2026 report entitled Reforming Rape Trials: The Impact of Law Reform on Criminal Trials in Australia, phone subpoenas commonly provide "fertile ground for the invocation of rape myths" within the court process. The Greens recognise that what is urgently needed is an absolute prohibition on access to complainants' counselling communications, unless the complainant consents to accessing these communications, as well as broader reform of the framework regarding access to other private records including digital communications and medical records.

I acknowledge that this is not a simple reform and also requires significant levels of investment to ensure all victim-survivors have access to independent legal representation to advise them on the nuances of consenting to accessing these communications. However, we already have an extensive body of evidence-based research pointing to the gaps in our system and calling for urgent reform. Notably, these issues have been closely examined by experts in recent years, including by researchers Julia Quilter and Luke McNamara, who were commissioned to undertake the first statutory review of the 2021 consent reforms, as well as research by the Australian Law Reform Commission and the Australian Institute of Criminology.

I also note that ground rules hearings have the potential to provide another mechanism for the timely identification of any issues with the sexual assault communications privilege. The notion of a ground rules hearing is focused on minimising distress, secondary victimisation and re-traumatisation of complainants. Access to a victim-survivor's intimate personal information is well recognised to be a profound source of harm and re‑traumatisation. That is why The Greens believe that independent legal representation for the complainant at ground rules hearings is essential for ensuring these hearings are effective, trauma informed and safe for victim‑survivors. Guaranteeing that survivors have access to independent legal representation would provide an avenue for ensuring that protections for complainants, such as the sexual assault communications privilege, are fully upheld.

A survivor's representative in court proceedings would be able to oversee compliance with notice requirements by the defence counsel, noting that, historically, noncompliance has been found to cause significant distress to victim-survivors. When subpoenas are issued without leave, protected confidences are commonly produced without the victim-survivor's knowledge, which can understandably cause significant harm and distress to someone who has already faced obstacle after obstacle in seeking justice. In addition, when leave is sought on short notice or retrospectively, victim-survivors commonly face difficulties accessing legal advice, which can lead to further delays in the court process or result in victim-survivors being pressured not to assert their rights to avoid delay.

The bill also makes some important changes to the Criminal Procedure Act 1986 to ensure that domestic violence victim-survivors have access to existing procedural protections currently only available for sexual violence victim-survivors. The Greens welcome those particular reforms and I note that the sector is broadly supportive, including Domestic Violence NSW and the Women's Legal Service NSW. These changes include enabling victim-survivors' original evidence to be admissible in retrials and subsequent trials of domestic violence proceedings, as well as expanding victim-survivors' access to alternative means of giving evidence in domestic violence proceedings.

The bill also addresses a particular gap by ensuring that a victim-survivor of domestic violence cannot be directed to attend committal proceedings unless a judge is satisfied that special reasons exist that require them to attend to give oral evidence, a protection that currently already exists for violent offences but fails to adequately recognise the seriousness of non-physical domestic abuse including coercive control. In addition, the bill removes the distinction between physical and non-physical domestic violence offences, which is a welcome and long overdue change.

Another welcome protection in the bill is the extension of the existing domestic violence evidence-in-chief [DVEC] provisions to include standalone apprehended domestic violence order [ADVO] proceedings. Currently, DVEC recordings are available for domestic violence offence proceedings and any associated ADVO proceedings, but they are not available for standalone ADVO proceedings. DVEC recordings can be an effective means of ensuring quality evidence in domestic violence proceedings, while also reducing distress for victim‑survivors going through those proceedings. However, those recordings do require careful consideration of the nuanced circumstances surrounding each particular case.

It is also worth emphasising that expanding the use of DVECs must be accompanied by comprehensive, specialist training for police to ensure implementation does not result in misidentification of the primary aggressor, a risk previously identified by the expert domestic violence sector on numerous occasions in relation to the use of DVECs. Another potential risk regarding the use of DVECs is the question of whether these recordings have the capability of properly identifying and capturing coercive control dynamics. In practice, it is not uncommon for a victim-survivor to have difficulty verbalising the abuse being perpetrated against them. I acknowledge the important work of frontline specialist domestic violence workers, who are best placed to answer these questions because they are the ones supporting victim-survivors through these processes on the ground and are well versed in the nuances of domestic abuse and, in particular, coercive control.

I note that the bill will commence on proclamation, which I understand is to provide the Government with sufficient time to develop standard operating procedures [SOPs] and practice guidelines for police to implement the reforms. The Greens are not convinced that there will be adequate training for police that is mandatory, comprehensive and trauma informed. In particular, our concern lies with police officers conducting recorded interviews, given that they will not be specialist investigators like we would ideally prefer. In New Zealand, for example, their SOPs include detailed guidelines, and recorded interviews are conducted by a small pool of trained officers. Those concerns also extend to the new DVEC provisions, including the potential risks in implementing them on the ground with victim-survivors.

To conclude, I once again thank the tireless advocates, victim-survivors and experts who continue fighting to improve access to justice for victim-survivors of domestic, family and sexual violence. The Greens will not stop fighting alongside them for the many reforms that our systems so desperately need. I flag that we will move amendments to the bill during the Committee stage. I thank the Attorney General's office for engaging with my office on the bill and our amendments in a genuinely collaborative manner, and for the commitment to continue engaging with us on law reform to improve access to justice for victim-survivors of sexual, domestic and family violence. The success of the changes in the bill will be heavily dependent on the resourcing and training that is allocated, as well as robust reviews of their implementation, which we will be closely monitoring and holding the Government to account on.

Abigail went on to secure 8 amendments to strengthen the bill and the rights of victim-survivors

Read the debate in Hansard here.

10 November 2026

Join 61,261 other supporters in taking action