The NSW Labor Government's solution to all of the problems facing society, including the rise of One Nation, is to—wait for it—put a cap on net debt

Today in Parliament, Abigail spoke in opposition to the proposed Parliamentary Budget Officer Amendment Bill (No 2) 2026, arguing that it is an out of touch, flawed election-focused tool major parties use to score political points, rather than creating policies to bolster those in the State who are doing it incredibly tough.

Abigail said:

On behalf of The Greens, as our Treasury spokesperson, I oppose the Parliamentary Budget Officer Amendment Bill (No 2) 2026. Before I start talking about why, I reflect on a couple of things the Hon. Mark Latham just said. The first is in relation to The Greens not having a leader. It is true. There are seven women in the New South Wales Parliament who are perfectly capable of coming together and making decisions based on what has been set for us by our party, but The Greens absolutely have a grassroots up culture, which means that we do not have a party leader that is a politician. To correct the record, David Shoebridge is our parliamentary Greens leader, not our party Greens leader. That said, I, for one, welcome our new overlord. The other point made by the Hon. Mark Latham was in relation to what was Labor's most notorious costing in the last election. I would say that it was the Local Small Commitments Allocation grants program. It had to add up what $400,000 times the number of electorates would cost, but only after we had called out that there was no policy. It was then found out that it had an election slush fund in one electorate, but that is another issue entirely.

I turn to the bill. Members may recall my contribution to the first Parliamentary Budget Officer Amendment Bill in June, which I do not think is on many people's "best read" lists—that is fine—so our opposition to this bill will not come as much of a surprise. The Parliamentary Budget Office [PBO] structure in New South Wales is deeply flawed; it is nothing like the Federal one. It is also a pale imitation of the model that was put forward by the Labor Government in 2010. An ideal version of the PBO is one that is available to all parties and one that allows costings to be requested outside of election times. Imagine a PBO model that allows the information that currently only the Government has access to to be utilised by others in developing policies. There could be a back and forth with the PBO to get bits of information, which would allow parties to present a fuller picture of the impact of their policy approaches, not just on a particular initiative but also in a broader context of savings and redirection of spending more generally. That could be really useful, but unfortunately it is not what we have in New South Wales.

Instead, we have a regime where the PBO process is routinely misused by the major parties in their efforts to, quite simply, score cheap political points over one another in the heat of an election campaign or to add a measure of validity to actions undertaken during the election that have been subsequently called out. The current regime constrains the PBO and restricts a policy's benefit to its financial aspects only, particularly short-term ones. In doing that, smaller parties are expected to adopt a major party conception of what sound financial management is and what the priorities should be in governing effectively for the people of the State. We are not considering how a policy impacts people's lives, the quality of our communities and their capacity to thrive, and the sustainability of the environment over the longer term.

This is a silly example, but one worth repeating because it does show how absurd the logic of the major parties is. They rely exclusively on debt and deficit, and short-term sugar hits and losses, and they take advantage of accounting tricks and even more convoluted financing to try to massage their budgets to make them appear to be the better financial manager. Imagine a party proposed to kill every person in prison, no matter their crime. On paper that would save an immense amount of money for the State, but the impact on society, our morality, our humanity, our democracy and the long-term financial prospects of the State would be absolutely catastrophic. Just because a policy will save money over the next few years does not make it a good one. And that is before we get into arguments about the externalities and other factors that should be considered when doing a costing. Anyone who has read a cost-benefit analysis for a major project will know only too well that it is primarily art over science and the tweaking of a myriad of assumptions in various ways creates wildly different outcomes, which brings me back to that first point.

If there was the opportunity to have a back and forth with the PBO outside of election times, parties could craft policies and costings in a way that specified clearly what the assumptions were and policies could be properly scrutinised with respect to what it was trying to achieve, rather than it simply being used to wield over other parties during an election campaign. A costing can be part of working out how viable a policy is, but it cannot be the only consideration. Unfortunately, that is what the major parties are trying to obscure with this bill, which underlines how desperately wrong their supposed efforts to tackle One Nation are. By attacking the symptoms rather than seeking to address the underlying causes and by refusing to do the hard work of speaking to other parties about what they need at this moment, Labor and the Coalition are bringing the debate back to familiar ground. They are trying to tackle the new opponent on the field that they are most comfortable with: neoliberal fiscal management. Coupled with lax corporate regulation, neoliberal fiscal management is largely to blame for much of what people are experiencing across this State: a noticeable decrease in the standard of living, along with an increasing frustration with our political and economic systems.

The Labor Government, in particular, appears to be hell-bent on doing whatever it can to make matters worse. Just when people are desperate for governments to have their backs, Labor is refusing to fund vital community services across our State. Just when people are crying out for their everyday lives to be made easier, Labor is cutting funding to a number of existing services. Just when people want governments to redistribute wealth from those who have far too much to those who have far too little and rein in the corporations and their profit gouging, Labor is doubling down on providing subsidies to some of the largest and dirtiest corporations around. It has now announced what is effectively an austerity policy for its potential return to government next year. Labor's solution to all the problems facing society is to—wait for it—put a cap on net debt. How out of touch can it be? I challenge the Treasurer to sit at the kitchen table of a family unable to pay their bills and help them work out which meals they may have to skimp on. Seeing them frustrated at the increasing complexity and burden on their lives, he can tell them not to worry because this Government will be making sure that net debt will not grow. It is so severely out of touch with the issues that people in this State are facing.

I am not surprised that Labor wants to elevate One Nation as its preferred opponent, but it is bizarre that the Coalition is getting in on it rather than rejecting this bill as well. That just shows how little chance the Opposition thinks it has in ever coming back to government. This bill is not the answer. Of course One Nation will not be fiscally responsible. Of course it will be a disaster. If people are asked why they want to vote for One Nation, they do not much care. They just want a party other than the major parties. They are so sick of the establishment parties driving this country into the ground. The idea that a Labor government cut workers compensation and funding for the early childhood sector and will not fund domestic and family violence services properly blows people's minds.

After a decade of Coalition governments at both Federal and State levels, people started to object. They were waiting for the moment they could vote Labor back in because they thought it would be different, but now they have seen it is almost the same as the Coalition on the major issues. People want something—anything—else. At the moment it seems One Nation may have some momentum, so people think, "Hell, it couldn't get any worse. Let's give them a go." If Labor wants to turn that around, it will need to put money back into the pockets of the people who are doing it incredibly tough. The Greens will go to the next election with a range of policies that would do exactly that. We are happy for our policies to be costed. We do not think it is necessarily required, or that the Parliamentary Budget Office [PBO] will do a particularly good job, because we do not think that is what voters are taking note of right now.

What we know is so much money is sitting in government coffers—like the billions of dollars in the early childhood fund that could go somewhere. Billions of dollars are being given in subsidies to the fossil fuel industry, for pokies—all of those things. It is not hard to say, "You know what? We could take from there and we could give it over here." We could take from the corporations. We could take money the Government is not using and put it into the pockets of people, giving them a leg-up when they need it. When people fall on hard times, we could say, "You know what? We will streamline the process for you to get your workers' compensation, because we know that no-one should get injured at work. We are going to create jobs, not just in industries that make things, but also in community services. We are going to put more money into health and making sure we have a strong workforce of people coming into the early childhood, community services and disability services sectors."

The Government could do those things to make people's lives easier and simpler. It would make them feel just that bit better about government and democracy. We are hurtling towards absolute catastrophe in this country. God forbid if we end up with One Nation in power, but that is exactly what will happen if the Government insists on putting up a bill like this in response to the threat posed. It is foolish. Part of me wonders whether they are trying to summon this other opposition into power with bills like this, to try and get rid of the Coalition forever. It is the wrong move. We should not do that. Instead, we should provide for people and present an alternative that is based on compassion and hope and acknowledges the material circumstances people face right now. We should not talk about net debt, the PBO and costings and all the rest. It is out of touch. We oppose the bill.

Read the debate in Hansard here.

22 October 2026

Join 61,333 other supporters in taking action