Today in Parliament, Abigail led for the Greens in debate supporting the Local Jobs First Bill and passed 34 Greens amendments to strengthen it.
Abigail said:
I indicate that The Greens will support the Local Jobs First Bill 2026 with amendments. To be fair to the bill, it is a step in the right direction, although it is my view that it falls far short of what many of us who have been advocating for this reform for some time had hoped. Nevertheless, it does real things that will make an important difference, and I support and applaud that direction of travel and urge the Government to consider this the first step and not the last. The principle that governs the heart of the reform is sound and overdue. The idea that the lowest price in a tender is not the same thing as the best value for the people of this State is correct. This Parliament thoroughly and comprehensively thrashed out those ideas over a number of months more than two years ago in the Standing Committee on Social Issues Committee inquiry into Procurement practices of government agencies in New South Wales and its impact on the social development of the people of New South Wales, ably chaired by the Hon. Dr Sarah Kaine.
Through that inquiry, we heard that New South Wales spends in the order of $42 billion a year through procurement across roughly 130,000 suppliers. Procurement is one of the largest levers that any government holds when it comes to the economic and industrial activities of its constituents and, for more than a decade, it was being pulled in the wrong direction. We heard plainly from worker representatives about the cost of a narrowly constructed view of value for money. We heard from the Australian Manufacturing Workers' Union, which told us of not only the dollars sent offshore but also a generation of manufacturing skills lost, and trains and ferries that came back late, over budget and, in many cases, unfit for the task they were bought for. Those issues were not new to us in that inquiry either.
As the former chair of the transport portfolio committee, I recall many hours spent in the previous term of Parliament prosecuting failures of transport procurement when it came to the cracks in the hulls of the overseas‑procured Emerald class ferries, the Balmoral, Fairlight and Clontarf, and their penchant for wandering off course. Who could forget the farce that was the inner west light rail trams, where every tram was found to be deficient in its construction, with significant and extensive cracking across the entire fleet? When those cracks were discovered, we realised that the trams that serviced the CBD light rail were not compatible with the inner west because they have a different wheel profile and were far longer.
The inner west light rail fleet was suspended for over 100 days before returning to limited service—a delay significantly attributable to the fact that nobody in New South Wales had the knowledge of the trams to conduct the repairs properly. Engineers from Spanish manufacturer CAF, which makes and services the Urbos 3 sets that ran on the line, had to be flown out to Australia from Spain to oversee the damage and repairs. The failure to create an integrated light rail network, the shoddy construction and extended repairs are proof positive of the need to prioritise local manufacturing, local design and local knowledge in New South Wales government procurement decisions, because we always end up spending more in the long run.
Those examples do not even touch the sides of the litany of transport procurement failures. But it is not only in transport where we can see the false economy of cheap offshored procurement and its harmful effect on the resilience and domestic capacity of a State and nation. Take, for example, the experience of New South Wales and Australia with personal protective equipment [PPE] and medical supplies during the COVID‑19 pandemic. At the commencement of the pandemic in early 2020, there was a shortage of PPE for health workers. Without PPE, health workers could not protect themselves against infection and risked taking COVID home to unvaccinated family members and those that they shared their homes with.
From as early as March 2020, the lack of PPE had serious health implications as it forced hospitals to stop elective surgeries and left patients and health professionals at risk. During the initial phases of the pandemic, Australia experienced supply demand deficiencies of personal protective equipment, leading to nurses and midwives reporting having to make face shields and re-using PPE and, in some instances, employers hoarding PPE rather than allowing its use. Australia was ill-prepared and suffered because of our place within the global supply chain. Available stock was either retained within manufacturing countries or flowed to demand from more lucrative markets, namely the United States and Europe. Under such pressure, the then Government entered contracts that failed to provide safe PPE, with a flow‑on effect on New South Wales.
For example, according to the Nurses and Midwives' Association, in 2021 there was $775.9 million of COVID-19 inventory impairments and write-offs. While there were improvements in 2021‑22, there was still $451.6 million in COVID-19 inventory impairments and write‑offs. The figures do not include rapid antigen tests [RATs], which are expected to account for a further $186.7 million in impairments. In addition to the impairments and write‑offs of COVID‑19 inventory and RATs, another $29.4 million has been allocated for disposal of impaired COVID-19 inventories. Australia, and more specifically the New South Wales Government, need to be able to circumvent barriers within free trade agreements as they pertain to local procurement. Indeed, there must be capability and capacity to always ensure sovereign manufacturing capacity for healthcare equipment.
The potential for profit to override the healthcare needs of our citizens and compromise the safety of health and aged-care workers who look after them must be negated through procurement practices. Of course, it was not just in hospital settings that the impact of PPE shortages was felt. Many GPs felt that they had been largely ignored by health authorities due to a focus on hospitals, with one respondent to a survey saying that it was as if they did not count as frontline workers. Many practices were forced to source products through alternative channels, with one South Australian GP saying that they paid up to triple the usual price, while a Queensland GP resorted to finding equipment at Bunnings in order to access PPE. Meanwhile, supplies allocated from the National Medical Stockpile, the NMS, were called "scandalous".
That was exemplified by a GP relaying an instance in which they received just one N95 mask per doctor at their practice following a request for support—a situation they described as a "complete joke". The lack of access saw 12 per cent of the 1,790 community healthcare workers who responded to the survey claim that they had been denied appropriate PPE when caring for suspected COVID-19 cases, with 59 per cent stating it was due to supply issues and 23 per cent stating it was due to rationing.
It also meant that 47 per cent of community healthcare workers had to re‑use or extend the life of their personal protective equipment, often by wearing items longer than recommended, re‑using single‑use disposable items or disinfecting items with liquid cleaner. These issues could have been easily ameliorated with a local manufacturer able to scale‑up to meet domestic demand. The way to make that local manufacturer viable in regular times and to create the conditions for sovereign domestic supply at times of emergency, as well as create good quality local jobs, is by leveraging government procurement dollars and mandating local content requirements. These decisions will always end up paying for themselves in manifold and valuable ways.
But it is not only New South Wales Government procurement decisions about physical goods that have a hugely significant impact on the social development of this State. We have heard countless times from workers in vulnerable industries—for example, in particular, cleaners and security guards—about the exploitation they face in their employment. Those industries are prime sites of forced labour, wage theft, exploitation and abuse, and it is incumbent on this Government to ensure, in no uncertain terms, that not a single dollar of New South Wales Government money—the money of the people of this State—is being paid to those who profit from the immiseration of workers.
The United Workers Union has told us that cleaning and security services are structurally vulnerable to poor employment conditions and are sectors where the New South Wales Government is well positioned to make a positive impact. These are also jobs that, by their nature, must occur in New South Wales. Cleaning cannot be done over Zoom and a security officer cannot protect their site from interstate or overseas. Government cleaning and security jobs are found in every corner of the State, and the union makes the point that investing in these jobs means investing in local workers and our regions. The security and contract cleaning industries in Australia are systematically plagued with compliance issues related to workplace rights and entitlements, and the mistreatment and exploitation of workers. These issues exist on a continuum that ranges from wage and superannuation underpayments and other award breaches, through to incidents of modern slavery that involve threats, coercion and restrictions on workers' freedoms.
The cleaning and security industries are characterised by a number of structural features that academics identify as increasing the risk of labour noncompliance, including the separation of oversight and diffuse accountability between building owners, contract managers and employers; commercial pressure to compete on price; vulnerable workforces; the use of casual labour and subcontracting; and labour cost minimisation as a dominant strategy. We have recently seen exactly that play out in a New South Wales Government procurement for security guards. The security services company M.A Services Group Pty Ltd collapsed into voluntary administration on Christmas Eve last year, leaving thousands of security guards abruptly sacked and owed entitlements. M.A Services Group held contracts with AFL clubs, retailers, government agencies and universities, all while the company was engaged in suspected tax evasion, worker exploitation and links to organised crime.
The Victorian Labour Hire Authority's analysis of the company's contracts revealed:
… clients paid rates too low for MA Services Group to cover its costs if it paid wages, benefits and taxation at lawful rates.
The issue highlights the need for action on multiple fronts, and to hold large, price‑setting companies to account for conditions in their supply chains.
The authority alleged that Coles' $50 million a year contract with M.A Services Group could not have supported proper paying conditions for guards and that the company knew workers would be exploited. At the time of the collapse, both TAFE NSW and the Northern NSW Local Health District had contracts with M.A Services Group, with the local health district having signed the contract after public reporting of the serious allegations against director Micky Ahuja had begun. Unlike the Victorian Government, this Government never removed M.A Services Group from any preferred supplier list nor took any proactive action against the company once those allegations came to light. There was clearly a profound failure to undertake appropriate due diligence into a company that should have been more properly scrutinised.
In its approach to compliance in the cleaning and security industries, the Fair Work Ombudsman [FWO] has turned its attention up the supply chain to procurers of cleaning and security services, and found serious deficiencies in governance arrangements with regard to the procurement and oversight of contracts, resulting in serious exploitation of workers occurring at multiple levels of the supply chain. The FWO has urged major Australian companies to, "take the lead in promoting a culture of compliance with workplace laws, beginning with their own contracting networks" and said that businesses need to "step up and be active in their responsibility to ensure that workers in their supply chains are being paid appropriately and treated fairly".
This model of "strategic enforcement" focuses on the role of procurers in driving compliance by setting labour standards at the point at which services are tendered and procured, rather than relying purely on auditing compliance with labour standards during the life of a contract. The FWO has recommended that procurers amend tender documents to reflect best practice contracting and labour standards, and ensure that the amounts paid in their contracts are sufficient for contractors and subcontractors to cover employee entitlements. It is precisely this culture of compliance in procurement that the New South Wales Government should be pursuing in its own procurement decisions.
The evidence that we have received—nearly universally from all relevant stakeholders with an interest in creating high-quality local jobs that will support the New South Wales economy and households—is that the way to do that is through the development of a code or standard in government procurement that sets objectives and requirements for procurement decisions to go towards funding work for businesses that meet the highest ethical and labour standards. In most instances, the model that was pointed to was the Secure Local Jobs Code, which has been in operation in the Australian Capital Territory since 2021.
That was the model suggested most often and endorsed by Unions NSW, which wrote in its submission to the 2024 procurement inquiry:
The NSW Government should ensure its providers of labour services are meeting their legal requirements to maintain appropriate labour standards. Unions NSW believes the implement of a Secure Local Jobs Code for procurement would assist in maintaining appropriate labour standards.
In preparing the submission, Unions NSW reviewed how other States and Territories ensure their providers of labour maintain appropriate labour rights and standards. Unions NSW is of the view the ACT's Secure Local Jobs Code is the most effective model. The ACT Secure Local Jobs Code applies to contracts of any value for construction, cleaning, security, traffic management and services and to contracts greater than $200,000 for services or workers where labour is the highest component within the contract (with some exceptions).
The ACT Secure Local Jobs Code requires tendering entities to obtain a Secure Local Jobs Code certificate through an independent audit. The Government's compliance body is the Secure Local Job Code Registrar who is responsible for assessing the audit report, certificate application and past compliance with requirements under the Code. Upon certification, the entity submits a self-assessed declaration called the Ethical Treatment of Workers Evaluation as part of the tender assessment process. The list of Code-certified entities are then published online in a public register.
The ACT Secure Local Jobs Code is an effective two-gate model for ensuring workplace rights and conditions are of the highest standards in industries in significant receipt of Government funding or procurement.
While the Australian Capital Territory model was the one endorsed most often, I note that it was not the only form that such a reform could have come in, with a number of other States also providing for worker protection and local content in their procurement rules. All other Australian States and Territories have local procurement policies. For example, the Victorian Fair Jobs Code was adopted in 2022, while Queensland has BPIC, the Best Practice Industry Conditions framework. Both models have enormous merit, and their best elements can and should be incorporated into a New South Wales secure local jobs code. It is therefore with not inconsiderable dismay that we consider the paucity of those elements in the bill before us today.
More than two years after the Government put out a press release on 1 September 2024 headlined "Dodgy suppliers to be banned from NSW Government contracts", and containing lines such as "It means dodgy companies won't get an unfair advantage over companies that act in good faith and meet the ethical standards and behaviours the NSW Government expects from its suppliers", one might have expected that this bill might have made some attempt to introduce the key measure this reform was supposed to deliver: a secure local jobs code. Alas, it is nowhere to be found.
What is contained within the bill is as follows. The Local Jobs First Bill will establish an entity called the Local Jobs First Commission and will enable the Minister to appoint a person to a role to be called the Local Jobs First Commissioner. The Minister will also be able to issue a document that will be called a local procurement policy, the aim of which is to promote the use of local content, support local manufacturers and prioritise small businesses in government procurement. The bill also amends the Public Works and Procurement Act 1912 to introduce a supplier debarment scheme. The bill creates a statutory role of Local Jobs First Commissioner. The commissioner will be appointed by the Governor and will be subject to the direction and control of the Minister.
The commissioner's role is to promote the use of locally produced goods and services—local content—the employment and development of local workers, including learning workers, and the participation of local manufacturers and small and medium businesses in New South Wales government procurement. The commissioner is to advise and build the capability of government agencies in relation to local procurement; promote, monitor and report on the implementation of the local procurement policy by the New South Wales Government, including advising the NSW Procurement Board about agency compliance; monitor supplier compliance with local procurement plans; and consult with the Procurement Board, government agencies and other bodies in relation to the commissioner's functions under the bill.
The bill further provides for the establishment of a Local Jobs First Advisory Board that comprises three union and four industry representatives as well as two independents who are not government sector employees, and it will be chaired by the commissioner. The board is to advise the Minister on policy and initiatives to promote local procurement and on the priorities and concerns of local suppliers; advise the Minister on the implementation and effectiveness of the local procurement policy and on the lawful and ethical conduct of suppliers; advise the NSW Procurement Board on the Procurement Board's directions and policies relating to the local procurement policy. The board may recommend that the Minister establish industry reference groups.
The local procurement policy that is to be established under the Government's proposed policy will define "locally produced goods and services" as goods provided in Australia or New Zealand or services provided by persons based in Australia or New Zealand. A "local worker" means a worker whose regular place of residence is in Australia or New Zealand. It will require the use of locally produced goods and services, the employment of local workers, and the participation of local manufacturers and small and medium businesses. It will also set requirements to promote the use of locally produced goods and services; monitor lawful and ethical practices across government supply chains and supplier operations, including due diligence requirements before awarding contracts; deliver economic, social and sustainability benefits for the people of New South Wales; and define compliance and reporting requirements for government agencies and suppliers under the policy.
The policy will also establish a future skills guarantee that sets requirements for the employment of learning workers, including apprentices, on New South Wales Government construction and infrastructure projects as well as require agencies to have suppliers prepare a local procurement plan for procurements above prescribed values. The local jobs first regulations will prescribe that the local procurement policy applies to any government procurements with a value of at least $7.5 million and that government agencies must require suppliers to provide a local procurement plan for any government procurement with a value of at least $7.5 million. The local procurement policy must require government agencies to allocate at least a 30 per cent weighting when evaluating tenders against the policy's objectives or give the same level of consideration if a weighted score is not possible for the evaluation.
The future skills guarantee will apply to infrastructure and construction projects and require that at least 20 per cent of the trades workforce is comprised of apprentices for procurements with a value of at least $7.5 million. At least 20 per cent of the project workforce will be learning workers for procurements with a value of at least $50 million. The bill will create specific targeted powers in relation to the local procurement policy, which will permit the procurement Minister to determine that a particular government procurement must comply with the policy other than those already specified in the regulations, and also authorise that the policy is not applied to a specific procurement at the request of the relevant portfolio Minister. Where exceptional circumstances apply, the order must be published on a New South Wales government website.
Further, the bill permits an agency head to authorise that their agency does not apply the policy to a specific procurement if the agency head certifies it is not feasible to do so. The regulations will limit that authorisation to procurements valued below $25 million and define where a procurement is "not feasible" including where local suppliers cannot adequately meet the needs of the procurement, taking into account quality, complexity, scale and availability of a suitable local alternative. Where an agency grants that authorisation, it must publish the authorisation on a New South Wales government website and provide a copy to the commissioner. The bill will also provide for an agency head to authorise that the procurement policy not apply to certain procurements if necessary to meet the needs of an emergency.
The bill also establishes a compliance framework in relation to the local procurement policy that requires government agencies to provide information to the Local Jobs First Commissioner if requested to do so; requires government agencies to notify the commissioner if a supplier is not acting in accordance with the local procurement plan; enables the commissioner to require a government agency to carry out a performance management process to manage a supplier's compliance with a local procurement plan; and enables the commissioner, following a performance management process, to decide a supplier is noncompliant and to name the supplier in the commissioner's annual report. We are told the regulations will prescribe steps that the commissioner must take prior to determining a supplier is noncompliant. The bill provides that a supplier may appeal the decision to the NSW Civil and Administrative Tribunal.
Finally, the bill amends the Public Works and Procurement Act 1912 to introduce a supplier debarment scheme and provide for the NSW Procurement Board to administer the scheme. The regulations will prescribe the grounds for debarment and operation of the debarment scheme. It is intended that debarment will apply to only the most egregious forms of criminal behaviour or a serious breach of civil statutory obligations by suppliers. That certainly sounds like the bill is doing a lot. But really a lot of the content of the bill is just layers upon layers of administrative process in an attempt to force government agencies to comply with really simple procurement principles—and they really need forcing. This Parliament has become very well acquainted with some really egregious examples of government agencies engaging in very poor procurement practices and failing to comply with the rules that already exist.
Examples can be found in the Public Accountability and Works Committee's report into the New South Wales Government's use and management of consulting services, which followed the then NSW Auditor-General Margaret Crawford's report entitled NSW Government agencies' use of consultants. The report was scathing, concluding that government agencies do not procure and manage consultants effectively. Further, the report found that consultants were not being used strategically and that there were insufficient systems to manage or evaluate consultant performance. The Auditor-General's report found numerous examples of noncompliance with procurement rules, particularly regarding procurement thresholds. This was not the first of the Auditor-General's reports highlighting concerns with the Government's use of consultants.
Then throughout the course of the inquiry, over 10 days of hearings and 95 witnesses, the committee heard stories of brazen conflicts of interest, of revolving doors between consulting firms, government agencies and political parties, and of cosy relationships with key decision-makers. The Auditor-General's report alerted us to the difficulties the Government as a whole had in accurately recording consultant expenditure and the disconnect between the main invoicing system, which just happens to be designed and operated by PwC, and other government records. The result was that no-one was able to actually give the committee a dollar figure of exactly how much the New South Wales Government is spending on consultants. As the Auditor-General had noted, there was no single data source that accurately captures spending on consultants. That is incredibly concerning from a transparency and accountability perspective.
The New South Wales eTendering system proved to be a hugely fruitful source of information during the inquiry, not for actually revealing what tenders and contracts were being made by government agencies but as a valuable source for uncovering variation after variation, and mistake after mistake, in what was being disclosed. All one needed to do was compare what was disclosed through eTendering to what had been disclosed in an agency's annual report, and an error was almost guaranteed to be found. The committee uncovered some extraordinary contract variations—far higher than those discovered in the Federal context—including a variation of 9,200 per cent in one case involving a contract that had been awarded by the State Insurance Regulatory Authority to EY.
The report found that the eTendering system needs to be urgently overhauled to ensure timely, accessible and complete records of all government tenders, and that those records should be permanently available, not disappear after just three months, as has been the case up to now. It also recommended that far greater detail be provided in the description of contracts, including the reasons there has been no tender process or a limited tender process and reasons for all contract amendments or extensions. My team and I have become quite the connoisseurs of the eTendering website over the past few years. I regret to inform the House that the quality of disclosure remains tragically poor. The public deserves much more information about the way that public money is being spent. With significant changes to procurement rules now coming into place with this legislation, we must be able to see much more detail and information in order to ascertain if the reforms are delivering on their stated purpose.
Noncompliance with the procurement rules was, in my opinion, one of the most significant issues raised by the inquiry. The committee discovered a very broken system with so many opportunities for bad faith actors to do the wrong thing and get away with it. The Procurement Board, which comprises department heads, was making guidelines with no real enforcement powers and relying on attestation statements from other department heads as well as themselves. In other words, the committee found they were marking their own homework, and not doing it at all well. We easily found examples of attestation statements that were wrong, had never been questioned by the Procurement Board and for which there were no consequences for getting wrong. It has to be said that the Government's procurement processes were simply not serving the purpose for which they were designed.
The report found that the resulting frequent errors by agencies likely contributed to higher expenditure from public resources than necessary, which, in turn, negatively impacts the public's trust in democratic institutions. I was pleased to see some of these issues being picked up and addressed, including by the Hon. Dr Sarah Kaine, throughout the procurement inquiry. Throughout the course of the long and protracted process that has led us to this bill, we have heard time and time again that the agency heads themselves are putting up resistance to these reforms. That gives me great concern as to their motivations in this regard, and is the justification for a number of the amendments The Greens will propose to this bill.
I also want to comment on the unusual decision of the Government to define local content and local worker as not a person or business from New South Wales, not even a person or business from only Australia, but, in fact, as a person or a business from Australia or New Zealand. That is, quite frankly, absurd. The entire thrust of the Government's argument is we need to spend the 40-something billion dollars of New South Wales government procurement dollars to benefit the New South Wales economy. It is difficult to see how expenditure in Western Australia achieves that, much less New Zealand. If you ask me, I suspect the secret reason for the desire to include the definition of local workers as being from New Zealand is to permit the ongoing rubbish conditions we are seeing in the privatised bus contracts, which are setting rates of pay so low that they are causing driver shortages, meaning the privatised bus companies have had to fly drivers in from New Zealand. The Greens will join with other members in seeking to limit that absurd prospect and amending away an international supplier from being classified as a local business.
I also reflect on exactly how long and drawn-out this process has been. As I mentioned earlier, the Government announced this legislation more than two years ago. In fact, reforms of this kind were flagged by Labor before the last election, so it is safe to say that they are long overdue. But even if we say we have been waiting for these reforms for two years, that is a long time considering the argument advanced in favour of these reforms. Double the $42 billion for each year of the two-year wait, and that is more than $80 billion in New South Wales government procurement commitments and investments that have not had a local content requirement and have not subjected suppliers to even the most minimal standards of scrutiny. What a waste, all for some inexplicable delay to deliver a package that falls short of the promise of a local secure jobs code for New South Wales. But all fine things come to those who wait. The many people who have advocated for reforms of this kind—though perhaps not of this exact shape—have waited long enough.
Let us get this framework in place and start the push for something bigger, better and bolder. I thank those who have been pushing for this reform for so long, including the Australian Manufacturing Workers' Union and in particular secretary Brad Pidgeon. He is a relentless advocate for the interests of his members and he takes no prisoners. I thank the United Workers Union, the NSW Nurses and Midwives' Association, Unions NSW and all its affiliated unions who put their weight behind that advocacy on behalf of working people in this State. I specifically thank director of campaigns and strategy Todd Pinkerton. I thank also research and policy officer Tom Edwards for his extensive submissions and research throughout the consultation process.
I thank Minister Houssos and her office. We have become very well acquainted over the course of negotiating amendments to the bill. I particularly thank Siobhan Armson-Graham and Mario Falchoni. It has been a long process but, by all of us proceeding with patience and in good faith, we have managed to secure some good compromises and improvements to the bill, which I have no doubt everyone very much wants to succeed. Finally, I thank the Minister for introducing the bill to the House. Let us bring on the amendments and finally get this done so we can all think about something else.
Read the full debate and the list of Abigail's amendments in Hansard here.
24 September 2026