"Renewable methane" is not as clean as the name suggests

Today in Parliament, Abigail contributed to a debate supporting the Electricity Supply Amendment (Renewable Fuel Scheme) Bill 2026 on the condition amendments are adopted, arguing that adding “renewable methane” to a scheme that previously covered only green hydrogen risks greenwashing and prolonging the life of the gas network.

Abigail said:

On behalf of The Greens, I contribute to debate on the Electricity Supply Amendment (Renewable Fuel Scheme) Bill 2026. The bill amends the Renewable Fuel Scheme to introduce support for so-called renewable methane as a new eligible fuel under the Renewable Fuel Scheme. The bill will amend the Renewable Fuel Scheme targets to have one green hydrogen target, and a new target for renewable methane and green hydrogen. The Renewable Fuel Scheme was established under the Energy Security Safeguard in 2021, and to date the only eligible fuel type able to generate scheme certificates has been green hydrogen.

The Renewable Fuel Scheme is a market‑based certificate scheme. Under the scheme, a certificate can be created for each gigajoule of green hydrogen produced, and producers can sell these to liable parties. Liable parties—gas retailers and self‑contracting gas users—must obtain and surrender certificates to meet their share of the scheme's target, or pay the penalty rate for certificates they fail to surrender. This bill will restructure the Renewable Fuel Scheme [RFS] in schedule 4A of the Electricity Supply Act 1995. The scheme currently has a single target. The bill will split that into two renewable fuel groups, each with its own target, penalty rate and certificate class. Group 1 is early producer green hydrogen. Its targets are 180,000 gigajoules in 2027, 420,000 gigajoules in 2028, 850,000 gigajoules in 2029 and one petajoule a year from 2030 to 2037. The penalty is $17.50 per gigajoule in 2027, then CPI indexed.

Group 2 is green hydrogen plus renewable methane, which is newly prescribed as a renewable fuel. Its targets are 1.5 petajoules in 2028, rising to four petajoules in 2030, seven petajoules a year from 2032 to 2037 and eight petajoules a year from 2038 to 2044. The penalty is $10.50 per gigajoule in 2028, then CPI indexed. The Government's intention is for the group two target to be largely met by biomethane, not hydrogen. Group two is the significantly larger group, and it lets the cheaper so-called renewable methane compete directly with green hydrogen. The only protected green hydrogen demand is group one, which is capped at one petajoule. In substance, this turns a hydrogen scheme into a broader so-called renewable gas scheme. That has serious implications for extending the life of the gas network, compared with electrification.

The stated justification for the shift from exclusively green hydrogen to a combination of fuel sources is that green hydrogen production is not taking off in the way that had been hoped. That is true. Green hydrogen production is not being sufficiently progressed under this market-based mechanism. I am not entirely convinced that the issue is with the technology, as much as it is just another indictment of the neoliberal approach to industry, which sees important matters of industry design—and, in this case, environmental sustainability—handed over to the commercial incentives of private businesses, leaving government to wring its hands at its self‑imposed impotence. However, whatever the reason, this bill seeks to diversify the allowable mix of fuels to permit the incentivisation of so-called renewable methane, which is apparently more commercially viable. Despite the Government's claims, it is not so simple as to simply substitute one fuel for another.

So‑called renewable methane is not as clean as the name may suggest. It is important to note that while technically "renewable" in that it can be derived from sources which can be renewed, biomethane is still methane, the leaking and combustion of which contributes to greenhouse gas emissions. The value of biomethane and other biofuels as "lower" emission fuels is heavily dependent upon their source and the nature of their end-to-end use. It is also predicated on the assumption that their source would otherwise be releasing emissions—methane—which are now captured and utilised as a biofuel with less intense emissions released. In many cases such as landfill, sewage, forest waste, those sources will themselves need to undergo significant changes as part of implementing a more sustainable circular economy. That is, we will need to drastically reduce our production of landfill waste, sewage and forest and agricultural waste and direct those residual wastes to their highest value and lowest emissions use.

Assessments of the role of biofuels will have to consider a range of factors, which will materially limit the amount of efficiently accessible and genuinely low-emission biofuel available. That is not compatible with moves to inject biofuels into the gas network as a broad-scale, long-term alternative. The example of ethanol production and blending is cited as a potential example to be followed, but that is misguided. Ethanol blending does not materially reduce the emissions of the resulting petrol. In many countries subsidising the practice has resulted in the expansion of source crops such as corn and sugar at the expense of higher value or more sustainable crops and land uses, while crowding out investment in more effective emissions reduction alternatives. A similar approach to renewable fuels would be at least as problematic. Renewable fuels should only play a role in emissions reduction in industry sectors that are hard to electrify and abate. Biofuels, hydrogen and other renewable fuels will have a role to play in replacing fossil gases and fuels in targeted circumstances where no other solution exists in the short to medium term, and where they are the most efficient, effective and lowest emissions option.

Any renewable fuel industry in New South Wales must be targeted at those circumstances and developed according to robust principles. In particular, large-scale substitution of fossil gas with biogases or hydrogen in the residential gas distribution network is not plausible, efficient or effective so should not be pursued. Residential use of renewable fuels as potential alternatives to the fossil gas residential network either fail to contribute to emissions reduction and improved household health or involve substantial unnecessary cost and risk to households. Broad-scale use of either in gas networks would represent an inefficient waste of resources of which economic supply is limited and would be better utilised elsewhere with greater impact. Any deployment of renewable gas in residential gas networks should be targeted to those areas and circumstances where efficient electrification is not possible in the medium term.

I foreshadow that The Greens will move a number of amendments to ensure that any expansion of the renewable fuel scheme will not serve to undermine its intended environmental benefits. We will seek to limit the sources of biofuels to that which cannot otherwise be avoided, reduced or employed for higher value elsewhere. We will also seek to move an amendment that would remove the incentive to blend biomethane into gas pipelines for residential customers in an effort to delay residential electrification. That is an inefficient use of fuel that should instead be prioritised for hard-to-abate and demand or price-sensitive industrial purposes. Finally, we will seek to amend the scheme to ensure that when the certificate trading commences next year, the cost of the scheme is not passed onto residential customers through levies on their gas bills.

The Greens support for this bill is contingent on the outcome of our amendments. We see it as a real concern that this legislation directly undermines our emissions reduction targets and seeks to create a framework for prolonging the life of gas as a fuel in this State. The Minns Labor Government has a real love for the gas industry, has confirmed it has zero intention of ever reaching a 100 per cent renewable energy mix, and seeks to embed 5 per cent to 10 per cent—or even more—of our energy consumption to be delivered by polluting fossil fuels in perpetuity. That would be climate vandalism and a grave betrayal.

Just a few weeks ago world leaders met in New York for the United Nations General Assembly, which coincided with this year's Climate Week. They raised the alarm while the world boiled through a record‑breaking El Niño. A new report shows the planetary life support systems relied upon by humans have deteriorated to their worst levels ever recorded amid ongoing pollution and habitat destruction. Of the nine "planetary boundaries" that help determine whether life can flourish on Earth, seven are being breached at their highest ever levels of transgression according to the latest Planetary Health Check, a process that was established in 2009. A disorderly approach to climate change will cost the Australian economy at least $2 trillion, and we are certainly on that disorderly path right now.

A recent United Nations report found that global heating will reach at least 1.8 degrees Celsius under even the most optimistic future, well beyond the Paris Agreement goal of 1.5 degrees. The report by the Nairobi-based UN Environment Programme confirmed overshooting the 1.5-degree goal inscribed in the landmark Paris Agreement of 2015 was now "unavoidable" and, despite some progress in addressing the human-caused climate crisis driven by burning fossil fuels, likely in the next few years. It stated, "… there are no good outcomes above 1.5°C." Heating of up to 3 degrees Celsius above pre-industrial levels could lead to glaciers losing more than a quarter of their mass by 2100, raising sea levels by up to 13 centimetres. Global food production could decline by up to 14 per cent by 2050 if there are not effective strategies to adopt. Human health, water supplies, nature, cities, infrastructure and economies could all be severely damaged. Some losses would be irreversible. Many communities may have to relocate or change their livelihoods. It described the goal of net zero emissions as an "essential milestone that cannot be skipped".

The New South Wales Labor Government has an enormous problem with gas. At this point it is, quite simply, a climate vandal. Just today it announced its plan to more than double the use of fossil fuels in New South Wales, starting with an announced major new firming tender that explicitly excludes batteries and pumped hydro. The new tender seeks 1½ gigawatts of new gas capacity, adding to the existing 2½ gigawatts of gas capacity currently in the grid. The tender comes as some of the country's biggest energy companies are seeking planning permission for enormous new gas generators. What these firming tenders do is essentially provide underwriting support for the energy generation projects. Gas has always been eligible to compete to win these tenders, but it has always been unable to compete because gas is always more expensive than renewables and, in this case, batteries and other storage technologies. This fossil fuel lobby-captured Labor Government has had to create a custom scheme designed especially for gas, which will lock in higher bills and worse climate outcomes.

This Government is not serious about reducing gas use, and that is what makes this legislation so dangerous in its current form. If this legislation passes without our amendments to severely limit the use of the biomethane to be produced, it will simply prolong the life of fossil fuel infrastructure by blending it into existing plants and pipes, enabling its expanded use but with a greenwashed label, exactly as it was with E10 petrol. This Labor Government are pathological liars. It will say it is doing one thing and give it a label that sounds good and supportable, but the substance of its policies is always a betrayal, a disappointment, dangerous or inadequate. Our amendments would go some way to resolving some of the glaring issues with the legislation.

Climate change is the single greatest moral challenge facing us all. We cannot afford to prevaricate, hedge or delay. This Labor Government is dangerous. It is a climate vandal entirely captured by conservative political forces, dark fossil fuel money, vested interests and a deep and profound immaturity when it comes to leadership of this State and this country. It cannot be trusted because at every single possible opportunity it sells out the people of this State, our most vulnerable communities, our children and our native environment by taking the side of the fossil fuel lobby. We urge support for our very simple and commonsense amendments.

During the Committee of the Whole that discussed this bill again in the following sitting fortnight, Abigail secured an amendment to improve incentive structures.

Read the transcript in Hansard here.

Read the details of the amendment in Hansard here.

Join 61,342 other supporters in taking action