Today in Parliament, Abigail reluctantly backed the Electricity Infrastructure Investment Amendment Bill 2026 because it makes data centres pay for the network upgrades they cause and so shields households from bill rises, while arguing that it is thin on detail and does nothing to address the industry’s emissions, water use, heat impacts, land use or the erosion of community say.
Abigail said:
I indicate that The Greens support the Electricity Infrastructure Investment Amendment Bill 2026, while holding our noses. The purpose of the bill is to provide mechanisms to impose certain conditions on data centres as they seek to connect to the network. The Government has released a set of data centre guidelines that are currently unenforceable. The bill seeks to provide some of the mechanisms for enabling some of those principles and supposed reforms. The bill itself sets no particular policy prescription. Rather, it creates a framework upon which policies and requirements can be imposed. Unlike many existing large energy users, such as smelters or mines, most new data centre proposals are concentrated in metropolitan areas, where the electricity network is already congested. Meeting the demand will require substantial upgrades to the electricity network. The only requirement the legislation does impose is on cost recovery, seeking to require that data centres pay the full cost of the network upgrades they cause to be incurred, which is an acknowledgement that they currently do not.
The bill also expands the definition of network operator. Under the current arrangements, electricity network infrastructure projects are financed through network operator revenue determinations. The bill seeks to provide alternative arrangements for financing those projects, which will hopefully result in bill savings for energy customers in the future due to lower financing costs. The bill amends the Electricity Infrastructure Investment Act to create a new category of regulated entity called "large load infrastructure" and inserts it into the existing renewable energy access scheme process in the EII Act. It allows the Minister to declare a large load infrastructure access scheme over the whole or a part of the State. Such a scheme authorises or prohibits access to and use of specified network infrastructure, or a class of it, by large load infrastructure in the area.
The bill also inserts new additional fee principles so that proponents pay the cost of supplying new additional network infrastructure. I have been raising the alarm over the uneven distribution of transmission cost recovery for some time now. That is because there remains a glaring loophole that allows big power users, including hyperscale data centres and industrial users like the Tomago Aluminium smelter, to bypass the costs of our energy transition entirely and lump the costs onto households. Under the existing Electricity Infrastructure Roadmap, the cost of building large powerlines and underwriting wind and solar projects is recouped over time through energy bills of customers connected to local distribution networks, but an exemption built into the scheme design allows large energy customers to avoid road map costs if they connect directly to the transmission network.
For some time The Greens and other advocates have been recommending that that exemption be removed, especially to account for the proposed construction of those immense data centres. If the exemption is not closed in some way and data centres are forced to pay their share, households will once again subsidise the profligacy of harmful and destructive industries. Endeavour executive Colin Crisafulli told our Public Accountability and Works Committee inquiry that the exemption would result in substantial differences in pricing for different power users, and the time had come to address "a potential inequity". Right now, households are hit twice: once by increased demand driving up power bills and second by subsidising the infrastructure that delivers to those large industrial customers.
In some small way, that is part of the issue that the legislation is purporting to address. But, really, it proposes to make a pretty narrow set of amendments. That is the crux of the issue with the legislation: It is very scant on detail and on obligation. Too much of the specifics rely on the development of regulations. I said at the start of my contribution that The Greens support the bill while holding our noses. That is because, at its heart, the bill is about creating an element of the social permission structure for the data centre industry. That data centre industry is a destructive one that should be resisted. Sure, the bill will help ameliorate some of the immediate energy bill impacts by causing data centre proponents to contribute to the additional infrastructure upgrades that they cause to be built to accommodate their immense demands on the energy grid. However, it does nothing to stop those data centres destroying the planet with their carbon emissions.
The bill does nothing to prevent data centres from consuming hundreds of millions of litres of drinking water every single day to power their air conditioning units. The bill does nothing to protect communities from the intense urban heat effects from those same cooling systems rejecting heat out into suburbs across this city and this State, boiling local neighbourhoods. The bill does nothing to protect vital industrial lands for socially productive industries and logistics. That is because this NSW Labor Government is hell-bent on ushering those dystopian tech bro nightmares into our State. Over the last few years, artificial intelligence companies like OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, SpaceX and Amazon have grown their demand for computational power to fuel their artificial intelligence products. That computational power comes from graphics processing units housed and operating in increasingly large data centres. The size and scale of that data centre demand is the real problem.
AI demand is responsible for more than 90 per cent of new data centre developments, and is responsible for 100 per cent of the massive data centres on the news. That massive size comes with an immense appetite for energy, water and land, and the potential for a huge impact on communities in Australia and around the world. But communities are demanding a chance to have a say. They are fighting back, demanding more rules over when and where a data centre can be built and where they can get their energy and, often, questioning whether we want those AI factories to be built in the first place. Opposition to data centres is, for some people, directly about finding an avenue through which they are able to express their opposition to those massive AI companies and technologies that are coming and threatening jobs, poisoning our minds, degrading our cognitive abilities, ripping off creatives and just generally making things worse and worse.
For other people, it is directly about the climate and environmental concerns. For some people, it is about impacts on local community amenity. For others, it is classic opposition on technical planning grounds. But put all of that concern and opposition together and you have a serious public policy problem. The Government's response is to make community consultation even more difficult, to undermine avenues for expressing concern and to try to steamroll those projects through as fast as possible before communities can express their views. In terms of environmental impacts, we are of course seeing immense water consumption. Overseas we also see waterways being poisoned from data centre activities. We are seeing millions of litres of diesel being used for backup generators by those projects just for testing, let alone when they actually get turned on.
If there is any danger that the data centre may have to turn off for even a couple of minutes, we are then seeing the explosion of energy demand that accompany them, which is driving the creation of new fossil fuel projects and the almost certain extension of coal-fired power generation in order to service the energy requirements of the economy as a whole. Even if those data centres claim to be bringing their own renewable energy, which they are not, at best most of them are around 70 per cent renewables including offsets and non-time-matched renewable energy certificates. The Government has claimed that, under the NSW Data Centre Guidelines, data centres must contract new renewable energy equal to 100 per cent of their annual demand. However, in answer to a question on notice at budget estimates asking whether that will be time matched, the Government stated:
The renewable generation and storage requirements in performance measure 13 of the Data Centre Guidelines have been set to achieve an average 80% correlation between new electricity supply and a constant demand (like a data centre) across a year.
Our read is that one-fifth of data centre electricity use will not be matched by new renewable generation at the time it is consumed. It will instead be drawn from a grid that still relies on coal and gas. Even if they were genuinely 100 per cent renewable, there will be a clear displacement effect, taking all the available renewables projects, taking all of the workers to work on them, and leaving the rest of industry and the State to subsist on the other energy sources. I feel confident that, if we proceed with the pace and scale of data centre development, we will see Eraring remain open for longer to service that energy demand.
In September 2024 the Department of Climate Change, Energy, Environment and Water warned the Minister for Climate Change and Energy, Penny Sharpe, that data centre growth directly imperilled our legislated 2035 emissions-reduction targets. The Government's response was to develop a fast-track mechanism to get bigger projects built faster. It is a focus-group-tested industry talking point to claim those data centres are for critical national interest data groups, like health records, banking details, driver licences and tax information. To say that we need every one of those data centre projects to proceed just to keep the services we already have is clearly nonsense. We have had digital health records, internet banking and online tax returns for decades, and the storage demands for that information were extremely manageable. What has changed is the advent of AI and large language models. That is what is driving this demand.
When people listen to industry talking points enough, they become quite funny. Industry tries to tell people that the data centres are for serving existing demand for critical services. In the very next breath, it will tell people that we need to build new, hyperscale, resource-guzzling data centres to be able to compete in the AI explosion and that, without those data centres, Australia will not be able to do as much AI, because they are needed for that AI use. It clearly cannot be both at the same time, and it is not. The truth is, at least 84 per cent of all new data centre developments are for AI use, characterised by high-density clusters of graphics processing units and particularly intensive cooling requirements as a byproduct of those increasing chip densities. That explosion in data centres is for AI, not essential services. They are slop factories.
I have been working for the last year with communities, academics and advocates to fight this Government's railroading of community opposition and push for stronger controls that put people and the planet first. The legislation falls so far short of what is demanded at this moment, it is almost not worth supporting. In fact, I fear that supporting it only serves a propaganda purpose: to allow data centres and the Government to claim those data centres pay their own way, when that is only true in the most narrow of circumstances and definitions. However, on balance, The Greens decided we will support this legislation because, with this Labor Government in charge, one thing is certain: We will continue to see an explosion in climate-destroying AI data centres. If that is to be the case, the only responsible thing for this Parliament to do is to support legislative change that would go some small way towards insulating households from intense electricity bill price rises.