The most effective fix for keeping our children safe in the early childhood education and care sector is better-funded, properly staffed centres

Today in Parliament, Abigail delivered a Take Note speech off the back of the NSW Government's response to the Portfolio Committee 3 inquiry into the early childhood education and care sector in NSW report, arguing that that profit-driven, private-equity-backed operators and a lack of regulation have compromised children’s safety and quality of care.

Abigail said:

I take note of report No. 55 of Portfolio Committee No. 3 ‑ Education entitled Early childhood education and care sector in New South Wales. I thank everyone involved, particularly the unions and the many teachers, educators and other professionals who provided their insights and experience. I also thank all those who contacted my office by email, telephone and other means for helping to shape my personal understanding of the sector and the issues affecting it. Members will recall that this inquiry was sparked by a call for papers under Standing Order 52, which I am grateful to the House for supporting. The documents that were returned uncovered a quite shocking lack of regulation and profit‑seeking companies running amok in the early childhood sector in New South Wales. The wonderful Adele Ferguson and her team worked with The Greens to expose what was happening. On the back of that work, the support of the House to initiate this inquiry was secured.

It is interesting looking back on the inquiry—the report was handed down a little while ago now in May—in light of the differences that have been seen since the Cullen decision. All the CEOs of the major for‑profit childcare entities appeared. It was fascinating to watch, and they ended up pretty seriously bruised. The CEO of Affinity Education was particularly under the spotlight. Affinity Education is one of the largest operators of early childhood education and care services in New South Wales and Australia more broadly. It is backed by private equity, which became an important aspect of the inquiry as the committee examined exactly what this meant for the quality and safety of children receiving care in for-profit centres. For anyone unfamiliar with private equity, these entities come in to squeeze profit out of an organisation. They will call it "running efficiently", but the whole model is to increase profits by raising fees and increasing service output while cutting costs wherever possible.

When the sheer profit-taking model at these centres—which the committee distinguished from the smaller, technically for‑profit services run by people with experience and an interest in early childhood education rather than pure profit-taking incentives—is coupled with a lack of strong regulation, the profit-making instinct is not countered and noncompliance with regulation basically becomes a business model. That is what the committee observed in those centres in New South Wales. Not long after the committee asked the CEO of Affinity Education a series of questions, he lost his job. The CEO of G8 Education, another large for-profit entity, also appeared before the inquiry. Its shares fell following his appearance, trading at 90 per cent of their pre-inquiry value.

By using the powers of the House to summons witnesses to parliamentary committees, we were able to get the CEOs of these large companies in front of the committee to understand their response to the accusations that had been put to them. Obviously, following the Cullen decision, the House is no longer able to do that. I note that Portfolio Committee No. 3 - Education's current inquiry into Redeemer Baptist School has been unable to force the heads of that school to answer the multitude of allegations and evidence that have been put forward regarding quite concerning issues at the school. I note that because this early childhood education and care sector inquiry was a great example of how Parliament, using its power under Standing Order 52 and its power to compel witnesses, can really make a difference and change the national conversation on a particular issue. I think the House was at its absolute best with this inquiry. Again, I am grateful to everyone who worked on it, not least the dedicated committee team.

There is no substitute for incredibly coherent, well-qualified and experienced teams of staff in early childhood services to keep children safe and provide them with the best quality education. I have spoken about this topic at such great length in this place prior to today that I will not repeat it. But the fact is that we would not have a situation where a paedophile could come into an early childhood centre and abuse a child out of the sight of anybody else if there were sufficient staff in that service. If there is nothing else that we can take from this situation, it is the idea that we should always have people working within eyesight of each other in those services, and that we need to do everything we possibly can to facilitate that. If there is nothing else members take from this but that, they will still make a massive difference when it comes to the safety of children.

During the inquiry we heard some shocking evidence from the police about how disconnected they were from all of the other parts of government and other agencies when it came to being able to keep tabs on where sex offenders might be moving. We also looked at the shocking disconnects when it came to Working with Children Checks, child protection, police and the early childhood regulator. None of them are speaking with each other. One good thing that has happened since the inquiry is the Government reforms to fix the ways that those systems and agencies talk to one another.

I had the privilege of having a one-on-one chat with a professor from America who had spent a lot of time interviewing prisoners in America who had sexually abused children. He was trying to understand what makes them tick. After interviewing a thousand of them, he advised police across the United States and in other countries on their systems and ways of picking up paedophiles. He told me that paedophiles who are identified in the early childhood sector are being picked up from being seen on the internet or other footage. Very clever software is used to identify what country they might be in via the background in the footage. Investigators can say it looks like this centre or that centre. Then they try to piece the information together to find out who it might be. That is how they are catching sex offenders in early childhood services, not because their behaviour is being picked up by other staff or by the regulator.

The conversation I had with him has really stuck with me. Before I had that conversation, I felt that there might be ways that we could deter sex offenders from the early childhood sector with perhaps greater punishments, CCTV cameras or some other way because of the risk of being caught. That might then incentivise them to go elsewhere, which is also bad. But I thought they might not offend if they felt that they might get caught or be identified after the fact more easily. However, everything that he was sharing with me was saying, "No, this is something that they will do if they're given the opportunity. The only way that you can actually prevent it is by not allowing them to be alone with children in the first place." Since having had that quite profound conversation, I took that information into the inquiry.

Also, I have often spoken quite passionately in this place about the need to ensure that we are funding the staffing of the sector in a better way, and encouraging and supporting the services that already run those "two pairs of eyes on every child" model of staffing. It is that perspective that I bring to the current debates around how we are funding—or not funding—community preschools and what we are doing with the funding of preschool programs within long day care and other not-for-profit settings. It is with that lens that we made the recommendations in the inquiry that the number one thing we could do in terms of both quality and safety of children would be to really foster that workforce.

In addition to that, we looked very closely at the other sectors that are leeching off the very commercialised early childhood sector. We recommended that the Federal Government look at a different way of funding those services, but because we have a subsidy system that goes directly to the early childhood operators, a steady stream of income goes from the Federal Government into services. We have evidence that around 10 per cent of that steady stream of funding goes purely into the profits of early childhood operators. Also, that steady stream of income is then used by real estate companies to build early childhood centres that they can then rent out to an operator or a service provider—who in a lot of cases is a related entity of that real estate operator—on a basis where they are charging per child.

It is like our children have a little dollar sign over their heads. Two equivalent properties could be next to each other—a Woolworths and an early childhood centre. The early childhood centre will get rented out at 10 times more than the Woolworths would be, purely because each of those children is treated as an income stream. Then real estate companies are building this into trusts and investment vehicles, issuing huge amounts of debt out into global capital markets, which in turn allows them to continue to build more and more of these things in lucrative areas on the basis that that income stream coming from the Federal Government will then fund the interest rate on the bonds that that particular real estate company has issued out.

To an extent, that incredibly complex financial arrangement explains why it is not just the early childhood companies that are in the ears of government, but also the real estate industry and others who have created a whole lucrative arrangement around the way that we currently fund and allow for-profit providers to run amok in the sector. On top of that, short training course operators and casual labour hire operators mean educators are working in multiple places at once. The report makes really good recommendations on all of that. Again, I thank all of my fellow committee members who worked on it. We put together a really incredible set of recommendations. Some of what the Government has responded to so far has been useful, but until we get better staffing, we are not going to make a difference.

Read the debate in Hansard here.

Join 61,342 other supporters in taking action